Consultant updates

Why Strategy Fails in the Middle: The Role of Senior Leadership in Execution

Why Strategy Fails in the Middle: The Role of Senior Leadership in Execution

Over the years, I have seen organisations invest significant time in developing strategies that are thoughtful, ambitious and well presented. The strategy is approved, communicated and often launched with energy. Yet months later, the organisation is still struggling with the same priorities, the same coordination issues and the same difficult trade-offs.

When this happens, the problem is often described as an execution gap. I think that is true, but incomplete. In many cases, strategy does not fail at the top where it is designed, or at the frontline where people are working hard to deliver. It fails in the middle — in the space where senior leaders are expected to translate strategic intent into priorities, decisions, operating plans and management routines.

That middle layer matters because strategy only becomes real when leaders make choices about what receives attention, what gets funded, who is accountable, and what the organisation will stop doing.

“Strategy becomes execution when leadership turns choices into priorities, priorities into accountabilities, and accountabilities into management routines.”


Strategy often fails through dilution, not rejection

Most strategies do not fail because people openly disagree with them. They fail because too many things remain important at the same time.

A leadership team may agree on three strategic priorities, but still continue supporting ten legacy initiatives, multiple donor commitments, internal projects and new opportunities. Nothing is formally stopped. Resources remain spread thinly. Teams receive mixed signals about what matters most.

This is where senior leadership has to do more than communicate strategy. Leaders have to protect it. That means making trade-offs visible and ensuring that budgets, people and management attention follow the priorities the organisation says it has chosen.

The middle translates strategy into operating choices

A strategy document usually describes direction. It does not contain every operational decision required to deliver it. That translation work sits with senior leadership.

Leaders need to turn strategic priorities into clear operating plans, key performance indicators, decision rights and review routines. They need to clarify who owns what, which decisions can be made at which level, and where cross-functional coordination is essential.

Without that translation, teams may understand the strategy in principle but still be unsure what changes on Monday morning. The result is activity without enough strategic movement.

Accountability must be specific enough to change behaviour

I have seen accountability described in very broad terms: a department is responsible, a team is accountable, or everyone owns the priority. In practice, that often means no one is clearly accountable for making the difficult decisions when progress stalls.

Useful accountability is more specific. Who owns the outcome? Who has authority to make the necessary trade-offs? What information will be reviewed? How frequently? What happens when performance is off track?

This is why decision rights and management routines matter. They make accountability operational rather than rhetorical.

Senior leadership should create an operating rhythm

Strategy execution is not a one-off implementation exercise. It is a management discipline.

Senior leadership teams need a regular rhythm for reviewing priorities, performance, risks and resource allocation. The purpose should not be to receive updates on everything. It should be to identify where execution is drifting, where decisions are needed, and where leadership attention can unlock progress.

The most useful review meetings are therefore not reporting meetings. They are decision meetings. They connect evidence to action.

Cross-functional alignment is where many strategies slow down

Most important strategic priorities cut across functions. A growth strategy may require programme, finance, people, partnerships and operations to move together. A shift in programme portfolio may affect funding, capability, systems and organisational structure.

If each function interprets the strategy separately, the organisation can become busy but misaligned. Senior leadership has to create shared ownership across functions, not simply cascade separate tasks down organisational lines.

This is especially important in nonprofits, where mission priorities, donor commitments and internal capacity can pull in different directions at the same time.

Leadership must know when the problem is not execution

There is another leadership responsibility that is sometimes overlooked: recognising when an execution problem is actually a strategy problem.

If teams repeatedly struggle to deliver, the answer should not always be more pressure, more reporting or another action plan. The strategy itself may contain too many priorities. The operating model may not support the ambition. Roles may be unclear. Capabilities may be missing. Growth may have moved faster than the organisation’s systems.

Good senior leadership means being willing to diagnose the real constraint rather than assuming that people simply need to execute harder.

Five questions for senior leadership teams

When strategy is not moving as expected, I would start with five questions: Have we made the few strategic choices that matter most? Are resources and leadership attention aligned with those choices? Does each priority have clear ownership and decision rights? Do our management routines help us make decisions, or mainly report activity? And are we solving an execution problem, or avoiding a deeper organisational problem?

If these questions are difficult to answer, the strategy may not be failing at the frontline. It may be getting lost in the middle.

For me, this is one of the central responsibilities of senior leadership: not simply to approve strategy, but to create the organisational conditions that allow it to move. Strategy becomes sustained results only when priorities, people, accountability, resources and management routines are aligned behind it.

About the author

Erwin Simangunsong, Strategy, Governance and Partnerships Consultant

Erwin has more than 20 years of leadership and organisational experience in international development, including senior leadership roles across Indonesia and the Asia-Pacific. His work has included strategy, programme portfolio leadership, organisational effectiveness, governance, partnerships and resource mobilisation.

He works with nonprofit and mission-driven organisations to strengthen strategy-to-execution, organisational capability, executive and board leadership, and partnership readiness. His approach focuses on practical choices, clear accountability and management routines that help organisations turn strategy into sustained results.